Jury sides with farm owner in Indiana
eminent domain case
By STAN MADDUX
Indiana Correspondent
LA PORTE, Ind. — The state of Indiana has been ordered to pay a
woman more than four times the amount originally paid for some of her farmland
used to widen a stretch of U.S. Highway 421.
A LaPorte County Circuit Court jury on June 28 awarded Janet
McNair $254,388. McNair said she would not comment about the case until after
Judge Tom Alevizos determines the amount of interest she'll collect in addition
to the judgment.
The Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT), in exercising
its eminent domain power, acquired the frontage of her property in 2010 to
widen U.S. 421 in Westville to four lanes between the north and south junctions
of Indiana 2, about 15 miles south of Lake Michigan.
According to court documents, the land totaling just over 10
acres consisted of 85 feet of frontage on the west side of the highway and 75
feet of frontage on the east side. INDOT went through with the acquisition as it
is legally entitled to do, but McNair challenged the $60,500 given to her for
the property.
She was asking for close to $900,000 for the ground adjacent to
150 acres of farmland in her family has owned since the 1960s. McNair did say
she currently pays a man to farm the ground, used for raising corn and
soybeans.
According to court documents, the state's offer was based on the
average of three separate appraisals.
Her attorney, Greg Kuchel of Schererville, argued the land was much
more valuable because it was commercially zoned in an area with existing retail
development and great potential for additional growth. He also said more than
15,000 vehicles a day travel that stretch of highway designated by the town of
Westville as a future high-growth area.
Kuchel said the state-ordered appraisals were based on frontage
of other properties within a 10-mile radius and not properly suited to base the
value of his client's ground. One site toward Union Mills had no development
nearby and only a bumpy gravel road alongside it, while another parcel in the
Wanatah area was unlikely to see any future retail or office space development
because of industrial buildings on the site.
"We're comparing, I think the phrase is, apples and
oranges," he said.
Kuchel also alleged the appraisers, although viewed as
independent, were too connected to the state because of previous work they
performed for INDOT. "I think that affected their valuations," he
explained.
Christopher Serak, legal counsel in the case for the Indiana
Attorney General's Office, argued the appraisals were done by independent and
experienced professionals. He also said frontage alone is not valuable unless
it comes with the land attached to it.
"Who's going to say I want to buy just this strip of
property?" he said.
Serak stated the value of the ground probably ranged from
$110,000-$280,000, with the most accurate figure close to the lower end of that
scale.
When reached for comment after the verdict, he said he is
prohibited from discussing cases and would not reveal if the decision will be
appealed.
|