U.S., Mexico agree on a resolution of sugar fight
By JIM RUTLEDGE
D.C. Correspondent
WASHINGTON, D.C. — A trade dispute with Mexico over sugar imports
has ended, with the United States winning a deal likely to lift prices of
sweeteners used by American food producers and consumers, the U.S. Department
of Commerce (DOC) and the Mexican government announced June 30.
The agreement was signed between U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur
Ross and Juan Cortina Gallardo, representing both the Mexican sugar industry
and Mexico’s minister of economy, Secretary IIdefonso Guajardo Villarreal.
Had the two countries not reached a deal, the nasty spat could
have erupted into a broader trade war, blocking efforts to renegotiate a new
North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) among the United States, Mexico and
Canada.
“We have gotten the Mexican side to agree to nearly every request
made by U.S. industry to address flaws in the current system and ensure fair
treatment of American sugar growers and refiners,” said Ross. “I’m glad to say
that Minister Guajardo and his colleagues to have been honest and collaborative
partners in seeking a fair and sustainable solution – this bodes well for our
long-term relationship.”
The agreement increases the price at which raw and refined sugar
is sold to Mexican mills by 3/4-cent per pound, reduces Mexico’s refined sugar
exports to the U.S. and suspends U.S. duties on Mexican sugar imports. Following
the announcement, President Donald Trump took to Twitter to say the pact was “a
very good one for both Mexico and the U.S.”
Among those pressing for the new trade deal was the Corn Refiners
Assoc. (CRA), which issued a statement praising Ross for an agreement “that
concluded in improved protections against unfair trade practices for sugar and
protection of nearly 4,000 jobs depending upon maintaining a vibrant corn
products market in Mexico.”
When the preliminary deal was first announced last month in the
renegotiated Suspension Agreement, The Coalition for Sugar Reform – which
represents Coca-Cola, Nestle, Kraft Heinz and hundreds of other food companies
– blasted the agreement as “a bad deal for hard-working Americans, and
exemplifies the worst form of crony capitalism.
“U.S. sugar policy should empower America’s food and beverage
companies to create more jobs, not put hundreds of thousands of good-paying
U.S. jobs at risk to benefit one small interest group.”
Since 2013-14 trade between the two countries has been anything
but sweet after the U.S. government found Mexico guilty of violating America’s
antidumping and countervailing trade provisions. A 2014 agreement struck with
Mexico failed to stop the country, which in recent years was said to cause U.S.
food producers to lose hundreds of millions of dollars to illegal trade
practices.
The new agreement suspends antidumping and countervailing duties
against Mexican sugar imports and sets new price and export terms favorable to
the U.S. marketplace. It’s a complicated agreement, but there are a few
elements drawing the most attention, according to the DOC. These include:
•Increasing the price of raw sugar sold at Mexico’s mill to 23
cents per pound from 22.25. For refined sugar at the mill, the increase goes to
28 cents from 26. These hikes exclude packaging and shipping. These prices should
protect the U.S. sugar market from harm caused by Mexico “dumping” sugar in the
United States.
•The agreement further reduces the percentage of refined sugar
approved for imports from 53 to 30 percent. This is a significant increase of
raw sugar available to U.S. refiners while ensuring that subsidized refined
Mexican sugar imports does not injure U.S. refiners.
•The dividing line between refined and raw sugar was reduced to
99.2 purity from 99.5, referred to in the industry as “polarity.” This means
that estandar, a common variety of
Mexican sugar, will count against the 30 percent limit on refined sugar. This is
to protect the U.S. sugar market against unfair competition from subsidized
refined Mexican sugar imports.
•To step up U.S. trade enforcement measures, Mexico has agreed to
accept significant penalties for trade violations, including a reduction in the
amount of sugar allowed for imports equal to twice the amount of any sugar
found in violation. In addition, the DOC can increase this reduction to three
times the amount, if necessary, to deter further violations.
•In a boost to Mexico, if the USDA finds that U.S. firms need
more imported sugar in any given year, raw or refined, Mexico has been granted
the right of first refusal to supply 100 percent of U.S. sugar needs.
Of the enforcement provisions, Phillip Hayes of the American
Sugar Alliance (ASA) said, “Trade agreements and U.S. trade laws don’t work
without strong enforcement. For too long, Mexico was allowed to sidestep our
trade laws, but those days are over.
“Our trade laws will be enforced. The U.S. market should return
to a level playing field, and U.S. farm and producer jobs will be saved from
unfair Mexican trade. It’s important that Suspension Agreements work as
intended this time, to completely eliminate the injurious effects of dumping
and subsidized sugar from Mexico and support the operation of U.S. sugar
policy.”
(ASA members include both cane and sugar beet producers and
processors. In Mexico, sugar is produced only from cane, according to the ASA).
The new agreement aims at
preventing the dumping of Mexican sugar on the U.S. market and corrects
subsidies the Mexican sugar industry receives. It further addresses concerns
raised by the U.S. sugar industry and will prevent harm to related industries –
including confectioners, beverage producers and corn growers – that might have
resulted if no agreement were reached.
Mexico is the top foreign supplier of sugar to the United States,
with a 12 million-ton sugar market where the Mexican government doles out
export quotas to about 40 sugar-producing countries each year through its trade
agreements. The U.S. receives about a third of those sugar exports.
The trade dispute escalated further last year when the U.S. sugar
industry pressed the DOC to withdraw from NAFTA over sugar prices and quotas.
White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer told reporters in January
that because of a nearly $60 billion trade deficit with Mexico, the Trump administration
was considering imposing a 20 percent tariff on Mexican imports. The new
arrangement puts to rest for the moment any suggestions of a tariff and opens
the door to expanded negotiations for a new NAFTA deal.
According to U.S. Census Bureau data, for the first 11 months of
2016 total imports from Mexico were worth $270.6 billion. Last year, the United
States bought $5 billion in vegetables and fruits from Mexico, an increase of more
than 4 percent from the year before. Mexico is the world’s sixth-largest sugar
producer.
The American Heart Assoc. says Americans each consume 19.5
teaspoons of sugar every day in various forms. That’s about 66 pounds each year
per person.
|