Mixed support for pundit to be
confirmed USDA science chief
By JIM RUTLEDGE
D.C. Correspondent
WASHINGTON, D.C. — Nearly two dozen of the nation’s top farm
groups have come out in support for the White House nomination of a
non-scientist to the top science post at the USDA, while a coalition of 54
farming, food and consumer organizations are urging the Senate to oppose the
appointment of Sam Clovis as the agency’s Undersecretary for Research,
Education and Economics.
Clovis, a former Iowa college professor and conservative radio
host, has received support from 22 industry groups, including the American Farm
Bureau Federation (AFB) and the National Corn Growers Assoc. (NCGA), which have
sent a letter to Senate Agriculture Committee leaders urging support.
The letter, sent to Sens. Pat Roberts, (R-Kan.) committee chair,
and Debbie Stabenow, (D-Mich.) ranking member, calls for a swift confirmation
process. A committee spokesperson said no confirmation hearing date has been
set, as they are still waiting for Clovis’ paperwork.
“As you know, we are strong proponents of our premier agriculture
research and education system in this country,” the letter said. “It is the
backbone for the productivity on our farms and ranches across the country. We
believe Dr. Clovis shares this passion and will work with you.
“Some have suggested that Dr. Clovis is not qualified for this
position due to his lack of hands-on-science and research experience,” the
letter added. “We do not share this point of view. The U.S. Department of
Agriculture already employs some of the finest and most dedicated scientists in
the world. They do not need a peer. They need someone to champion their work
before the administration, the Congress and all consumers around the world.”
The letter was signed by the American Soybean Assoc., National
Barley Growers Assoc., National Cattlemen’s Beef Assoc., National Cotton Council,
the NCGA, National Council of Farmer Cooperatives, National Grange, National
Milk Producers Federation, National Pork Producers Council, National Potato
Council, National Sorghum Producers, National Sunflower Assoc., Southern Peanut
Farmers Federation, Southwest Council of Agri-Business, the AFB, United Egg
Producers, USA Dry Pea and Lentil Council, U.S. Apple Assoc., USA Rice Federation,
U.S. Canola Assoc., U.S. Dry Bean Assoc. and the Western Growers Assoc.
USDA Secretary Sonny Perdue said, “Dr. Clovis was one of the
first people through the door at USDA in January and has become a trusted
advisor and steady hand as we continue to work for the people of agriculture.
He looks at every problem with a critical eye.”
The nomination of Clovis has drawn close scrutiny for a science
post that ranks among “the most critical” science and technology positions in
the federal government, as cited in a 2008 report by the National Academy of
Sciences.
According to an analysis by the Washington Post, Clovis is only the 11th nominee to be named to
fill 45 of the top Senate-confirmed science jobs across the federal government
in this administration. Clovis’ presumptive USDA $3 billion portfolio oversees
the critical Agricultural Research Service, the Economic Research Service, the
National Agricultural Statistics Service and the National Institute of Food and
Agriculture.
As the under secretary, the post also serves as the USDA’s chief
scientist, which according to the 2008 farm bill specifies that appointees to
the post should be selected “from among distinguished scientists with
specialized training or significant experience in agricultural research,
education and economics.”
Clovis’ résumé shows he holds a B.S. in political science from
the Air Force Academy, served 25 years in the Air Force including time as a
fighter pilot and holds an MBA and a doctorate in public administration. He
also taught economics and business at Morningside College, a small liberal arts
school in Sioux City, Iowa.
Since his nomination in July, opposition to Clovis has been
growing steadily. Several media outlets have reported on a controversial 2014
interview he gave with Iowa Public Radio, when he said he was “extremely skeptical”
about climate change.
He told listeners “a lot of the science is junk science. It’s not
proven: I don’t think there’s any substantive information available to me that
doesn’t raise as many questions as it does answers. So I’m a skeptic.”
Late last month a diverse coalition of 54 farming, food, consumer
and environmental organizations and others called on the Senate to reject
Clovis, calling his nomination “a direct attack on science and our food and
farm system.”
In a letter to senators opposing the nomination, the groups –
including Friends of the Earth, ActionAid USA, the National Family Farm
Coalition, Patagonia and the Sierra Club – said he “lacks the formal training
in the hard sciences and expertise in food and agriculture policy” to serve in
the USDA post.
“Clovis’ nomination is an affront to America’s farmers and
citizens who deserve a healthy resilient food system,” said Kendra Klein, staff
scientist at Friends of the Earth.
Additionally, the Food Policy Action (FPA) organization has a
launched an online petition calling on the Senate to block the nomination. The
petition is being distributed to FPA’s nationwide network of activists,
advocates, farmers, chefs and restaurateurs.
“Sam Clovis has no business being nominated, let alone voted on, as
a USDA’s chief scientists,” the petition states. “His complete lack of science
experience and disturbing views make him wholly unqualified and unfit for this
critically important position at USDA. Clovis’ only connection to food and
agriculture seems to be that he grew up in Iowa.”
|