AEM, NFMS agreement talks end over
fundamental differences
By JAMIE SEARS RAWLINGS
Kentucky Correspondent
LOUISVILLE, Ky. — Talks that would have created an unprecedented
partnership for the National Farm Machinery Show in Louisville, Ky. have ended,
according to the Association of Equipment Manufactures (AEM), who backed away
from negotiations because of fundamental differences in the two groups’
goals.
AEM and the Kentucky State Fair Board, who manages the National
Farm Machinery Show, signed a letter of intent and announced a verbal agreement
in February to create a partnership where the association would assist with
management and co-production of the annual show. At nearly 1.2 million square
feet of indoor exhibit space and attracting nearly 300,000 attendees, the
National Farm Machinery Show is considered the nation’s largest indoor farm
show.
“I think they saw value in
us that we have a successful show already established, and we saw value in them
that they are an industry leader in putting on trade shows and exhibitions,”
said Steve Kelly, executive director of expositions for the Kentucky State Fair
Board.
For AEM, the potential collaboration was a chance for them to
achieve the goals of their membership, especially in the agriculture sector.
“We as the AEM, have a charge from our members to create
meaningful engagement between their customers and equipment manufacturers,”
said Curt Blades, senior vice-president, agriculture services.
“We do that a number of different ways, and one of the ways that
has been proven successful over the years is through trade shows.”
“We service five industries- construction, mining, utilities,
forestry, and agriculture.”
“We have strong trade show presences in all of those areas with
agriculture being the weakest of all of those.”
“Knowing the position that the NFMS in Louisville has always had
with its nice attendance and certainly its strong exhibitor presence, it seemed
like a really great opportunity for us to have a partnership.”
According to Kelly, over the course of the nearly nine-month
negotiation with several meetings and correspondences, it became clear that the
two groups’ goals diverged in several key areas.
The first issue at odds—the gathering of demographic data from
show attendees.
“If an exhibitor is going to spend the millions of dollars that
they spend as a big exhibitor even the thousands of dollars as a small
exhibitor, it’s a big proportion of their marketing dollars, and we feel very
strongly that they need to know who is attending a particular show,” Blades
said.
“With all of the AEM shows, we feel pretty strongly about having
some sort of registration.”
“Our members need leads, but they also know they are reaching the
right audience and can measure their return on investment.”
KFSB believed that this change would be a fundamental difference
to the show’s core principles.
“AEM’s approach to gathering that demographic data is making it a
trade show where you have to register to get it,” Kelly said.
“That’s a philosophical difference in what the National Farm
Machinery Show is.”
“We open our doors to everyone.”
“We don’t even charge an admission.”
“We want to keep it open to the public,” Kelly said.
Additionally, AEM sought control over the show’s exhibitor floor
plan in the agreement, which Kelly believed could have been at the detriment to
long-standing exhibitors that had helped build the 52-year-old show.
“We felt like we needed to maintain the relationships that we’ve
built over the years and not allow someone else to come in and move exhibitors
around and put them where they thought they needed to be,” Kelly said.
“There’s value to that, because we do feel that AEM, had we been
able to work out a deal, would have helped us maximize our income or profits
from this show by utilizing space better maybe than we do now.”
“But at the same time, our board felt like we couldn’t do that at
the expense of upsetting our current vendors.”
Both groups are hopeful that meaningful negotiations could resume
in the future.
“I see the value of having a relationship and a partnership with
AEM,” Kelly said.
“They have an agriculture sector board that is some of the
largest manufactures that participate in the show, so obviously we would love
to continue to work with them, but I think right now as far as a partnership or
an agreement, we’re just way too far apart with what they would like to see
with what our board would like to see.”
“We do value what they bring to the table and we understand that
they are great at what they do, but at this time we are just not willing to
give up that control of the relationships we’ve built over the last 50 years.”
Blades echoes the sentiment.
“I would love nothing more than to forge a relationship with any
reputable trade show, including the National Farm Machinery Show, and I remain
hopeful that there will be a chance for us to work together in the future,” he
said.
“If the opportunity presents itself for us to have another
meaningful conversation with the National Farm Machinery Show and the KSFB,
we’d love to do that, but at this point, I don’t know that its in the cards at
least in the foreseeable future.”
|