Search Site   
News Stories at a Glance
Michigan, Ohio latest states to find HPAI in dairy herds
The USDA’s Farmers.gov local dashboard available nationwide
Urban Acres helpng Peoria residents grow food locally
Illinois dairy farmers were digging into soil health week

Farmers expected to plant less corn, more soybeans, in 2024
Deere 4440 cab tractor racked up $18,000 at farm retirement auction
Indiana legislature passes bills for ag land purchases, broadband grants
Make spring planting safety plans early to avoid injuries
Michigan soybean grower visits Dubai to showcase U.S. products
Scientists are interested in eclipse effects on crops and livestock
U.S. retail meat demand for pork and beef both decreased in 2023
   
Archive
Search Archive  
   
Ag recession may increase need for mediation services

By DR. MICHAEL D. ROSMANN
Farm and Ranch Life 
 
A farm mediation specialist called me three weeks ago. The mediator said there are rumblings that low farm commodity prices are triggering an uptick in distressed loans that could lead to an increased need for farm debt mediation services. The caller also was looking for information about how to recognize when clients need behavioral health services.
The professional mediator described a situation that occurred several years ago with a farm family involved in mediation. The couple were about to lose their farm home after sustaining recurrent losses in their cattle-feeding business.
During a mediation session with their lenders, the husband became volatile and refused to consider any options. His wife reluctantly accompanied him as he stormed out of the meeting. The next day the mediator heard the husband had hit his wife at their home, injuring her.
Should the mediator have better gauged the couple’s need for behavioral health care or some other kind of assistance? I determined to answer the mediator’s question.  This column resulted from the further consideration I gave to her query.
What is professional mediation? Mediation is a process of dispute resolution that can be undertaken when prior discussions among the disputants and their representatives, such as attorneys, have not led to a satisfactory agreement among the disputants.
There are a variety of mediation strategies. Trained mediators – preferably two people working together – help the disputants sort through issues together in a fair fashion that gives all the involved parties opportunity to express their positions, and to guide them through negotiation and compromise to reach agreement.
Sometimes the disputants remain physically apart and the mediators go back and forth among the parties to exchange information and proposals. Mediation can be undertaken to attempt to settle a variety of disputes, such as custody of children in a divorce, differences over contracts or almost any intractable disagreement.
This column focuses on farm dispute mediation. As I developed it, I drew on my 35 years’ experience helping agricultural families and corporations, as well as courts, to resolve farming-related conflicts of all types. I am not a certified farm mediation specialist; I am a licensed psychologist.
If mediation does not succeed in resolving a farm dispute, usually the next steps are binding arbitration, in which the parties agree to accept an arbitrator’s recommended solution, or a lawsuit. Both of these methods of resolving disagreements are usually more expensive for the disputants, and often they yield less control over the outcome and less palatable outcomes than negotiated settlements.
Mediation is a learning process. The participants can learn valuable skills such as, but not limited to:
•How to listen to others and to adhere to rules of decorum such as refraining from interruptions and making threats, and to take adequate time to consider matters
•How to negotiate, rather than dominate
•To appreciate other points of view that enlarge the understanding of issues
•To set aside one’s personal satisfaction only in favor of joint compromise among disputants as a healthier outcome that reduces anger, repairs hurts and builds the possibility of mutually positive relations in the future
•To practice confidentiality, fairness, respect, tolerance, humility and trust
•When to bring in outside expertise, such as farm business consultants and professionals of all types, including behavioral health care providers
When is it beneficial to bring in outside expertise to the mediation process? There is no single answer to the question, but a general guideline is when the mediation is not progressing toward reduction of the differences among the disputants.
All the disputants and mediators have the right to request additional expertise, but only to resolve the stalemate and not to bolster one party over the other participants. The mediators should encourage the participants to share in the determination of whether to request additional input.
In the situation described by the professional mediator who called me, it may have helped if a behavioral health counselor who understood farming had been present to support the farm couple and assist them in managing their frustrations.
The USDA Agricultural Mediation Program began as part of the Agricultural Credit Act of 1987 to help states develop USDA Certified State Agricultural Loan Mediation Programs. The Act authorized $7.5 million for the fiscal years 1988-91 to assist states through matching grants to deal with farm credit disputes in response to the 1980s Farm Crisis. The Act was extended through fiscal 1995.
The farm bill that went into effect in 2014 lowered the amount of USDA funds available to agricultural states to provide farm debt mediation services – $3 million in grants are available yearly on a competitive basis through matching state funds, to provide farm debt mediation and related conflict resolution services.
Currently, 34 states offer agricultural mediation services.
A list of these states and contact information is available online at www.rma.usda.gov/regs/mediation.html

Michael R. Rosmann, Ph.D. is on the adjunct faculty of the University of Iowa, author of Excellent Joy: Fishing, Farming, Hunting and Psychology, lectures across the United States and abroad, owns a row crop farm in Harlan, Iowa – and loves hearing new jokes.
He is a founding partner of the nonprofit network AgriWellness, Inc. Email thoughts and questions to him, and find recently published columns available for a small fee, through his website at www.agbehavioralhealth.com
12/3/2015