Search Site   
News Stories at a Glance
Michigan, Ohio latest states to find HPAI in dairy herds
The USDA’s Farmers.gov local dashboard available nationwide
Urban Acres helpng Peoria residents grow food locally
Illinois dairy farmers were digging into soil health week

Farmers expected to plant less corn, more soybeans, in 2024
Deere 4440 cab tractor racked up $18,000 at farm retirement auction
Indiana legislature passes bills for ag land purchases, broadband grants
Make spring planting safety plans early to avoid injuries
Michigan soybean grower visits Dubai to showcase U.S. products
Scientists are interested in eclipse effects on crops and livestock
U.S. retail meat demand for pork and beef both decreased in 2023
   
Archive
Search Archive  
   
Consolidating seed industry hurts farmers

One of the worst meals of my life occurred on a stormy June evening in the early 1980s at Milwaukee’s Pfister Hotel. The main course that night was a stringy, tasteless filet of me that my bosses at Successful Farming magazine served up to an unhappy advertiser, Allis Chalmers.

The sin that put me on the spit was a wisecrack - OK, I might have made it in print to a million or so of SF’s readers - on how AC’s no-till corn planters were still fighting soil erosion despite their ancient, 1950s engineering: most had been dumped into the nearest ditch shortly after Deere introduced its Max Emerge planter in the 1970s.
When that joke saw ink telephone lines between West Allis, Wis. and Des Moines caught fire. Two minutes later my professional food chain - me, my senior editor, SF’s editor and its publisher - were in the air for a supper of Wisconsin beer and Iowa crow.
During dinner, Jim, the publisher, made an eloquent apology while AC’s boss, a tight-lipped man named Roy, sat motionless amid a wedge of nodding vice presidents.

When Jim finished, Roy rose to acknowledge Jim’s “unbelievable” love (true; I didn’t believe it) for the color orange and his warm words about AC’s “century of devotion” to American farmers. He then raised his beer, shook Jim’s hand and life went on.
For a while, anyway. Within two years, Roy and AC were gone; in 1985, AC’s farm equipment line was sold. Most orange tractors seen today are either in parades or ditches.

Me? I’m still around and I’m still practicing the key lesson learned that night in Milwaukee: the best way for editors and publishers to avoid awkward meals in big city hotels is for writers to avoid unpleasant stories.

That’s why I’m not going to write about another unpleasant, Monsanto-focused seed industry study released Dec. 9. So what if it notes “at least 200 independent seed companies have been lost in the last 13 years” and “in fact,” 2009 “marked the first reduction of GE (genetically engineered) soybean acres since their introduction in 1996”?

As stunning as those facts might seem, there’s no way I’m gonna’ report on what they mean to you, your farm and your community because I doubt this newspaper’s editor and publisher want to eat dinner in St. Louis tonight. I know I don’t.

But if you’re curious, point your web browser to www.farmertofarmercampaign.org and click. Once there, you may - I’m just guessin’ here - find a report titled something like Out of Hand: Farmers Face the Consequences of a Consolidated Seed Industry.

I’m not gonna’ face nothing (nor will this paper’s brilliant editor and publisher) because I’m but a vessel here, a ship passing in the night somewhere on Lake Michigan.

On the cruise, however, I’ll likely pass www.manitobacoop erator.ca, another port with several Big Seed-related stories. I think some even examine Monsanto’s fascinating new Violator Exclusion Policy implemented in Canada on Oct. 19.

Since I will never write about it - as the Manitoba Co-Operator did Oct. 21, Nov. 12 and Nov. 26 - I won’t have to worry about jamming up my many editors over Monsanto’s formal policy whereby patent “violators who do not reach a settlement with Monsanto and whose violation results in Monsanto having to go to court, lose all access to current and future Monsanto technologies.”

I mean the brave editors and the publishers who stand alongside your cowardly columnist don’t deserve to be bothered now or in their lifetimes about what I won’t write about, right?

So, no, I’m not ever going there or, for that matter, back to the Pfister, mister.
But here’s news: crow tastes like chicken.

The views and opinions expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of Farm World. Readers with questions or comments for Alan Guebert may write to him in care of this publication.

12/16/2009